| With the Kyoto Protocol’s entry into force in February
                  2005, global emissions of greenhouse gases, or GHG emissions,
                  have attracted growing attention. In its response to climate
                  change, the Government of Japan has established its plan to
                  achieve its numerical targets and comply with the Kyoto Protocol.
                  Thus, national efforts to control and reduce emission have
                  been accelerated in every layer of the Japanese society. In
                  addition, GHG accounting/reporting/disclosure regulation will
                  be introduced in accordance with the Amended Law Concerning
                  the Promotion of the Measure to Cope with Global Warming. On
                  the part of business, operators with consciousness of social
                  responsibility have been reinforcing their efforts in view
                  of environmental management and emissions reduction/control. Meanwhile, ISO14064 will be formally adopted as a part of
                  the ISO14000 family, or the international standard of environmental
                  management, to serve as a guideline for voluntary GHG accounting/reporting
                  in March 2006.
  The biggest benefit to be gained from adopting ISO14064
                      is enhanced reliability. Given the benefit, Japanese operators
                      could consider two definite objectives: to facilitate effective
                      internal control on their emissions control/reduction activities
                      and to demonstrate their action externally.   In the area of internal control, ISO14064 is useful as
                      it systematically represents a series of basic principle
                      and procedures in GHG accounting/reporting. It will not
                      serve as an accounting tool per se for operators to calculate
                      and identify concrete figures of emissions or emission
                      reductions. But it will serve as a guideline to use specific
                      accounting tools and programs on their own by applying
                      ISO concept and procedures. Thus, it allows them to use
                      more flexibly to meet their objectives or needs such as
                      internal/external auditing. In other words, ISO14064 will
                      ensure certain quality and reliability for each operator
                      in GHG accounting and reporting depending on the degree
                      of their requirements. No less important is the fact that ISO14064 is a voluntary
                      standard and that it is designed to be used flexibly to
                      meet diverse needs. Thus, any application that hampers
                      the flexibility is adverse to users’ primary intentions.
                      We have a strong concern that ISO14064 would function as
                      a de-facto standard or mandatory obligation that require
                      business operators to comply in order to complete business
                      deals or to meet requirements for incentive measures or
                      environmental ratings.
  Also, the administrative organization should not add special
                      rules or interpretation to it. All of these actions would
                      be detrimental to original functions and advantages designed
                      in ISO14064.  With respect to disclosure, adoption of ISO14064 is expected
                      to give operators a “carte blanche” that would ensure quality
                      and reliability of their reports. Thus, operators would
                      feel it easier to let stakeholders and others in the society
                      to understand and assess their own efforts and endeavors
                      in controlling and reducing emissions. Depending on their
                      objectives and needs, they can use it for internal and
                      external auditing and verification processes. To enhance
                      reliability in publicly released data and information is
                      extremely important for operators to perform their social
                      responsibilities. At the same time, it is also essential
                      for the society and stakeholders to understand operators’
                      efforts to reduce emissions. And the function could be
                      reinforced with the application of ISO 14064. Another benefit of ISO14064 that one can think of is comparative
                      advantage to other competitors, although the rationale
                      is hard to prove at this moment. There are two reasons
                      that it is unlikely: 1) it never enables automatic comparison
                      of performance with others. To compare and contrast with
                      other competitors in a same industry, a common set of program
                      and tool should be shared among them. Yet, provision of
                      data and information based on such criteria is still limited.
                      2) Operators/suppliers as well as consumers/stakeholders
                      who choose products and services have yet to recognize
                      that GHG emissions-related performance is a key factor.
  The mounting concern about GHG emissions on the part of
                      the society and stakeholders could trigger more business
                      commitments or initiatives. In that case, businesses can
                      use ISO14064 for setting a certain comparable indicators/measurement,
                      appeal their higher performances in GHG and finally gain
                      competitive advantage.   In conclusion, the potential and future direction of ISO14064
                      would be as follows: ISO14064 has a potential to increase
                      efficiency and quality of GHG emissions control process
                      in internal/external auditing or IR activities, enhance
                      reliability of reporting data/information and by offering
                      flexibility to meet users’ needs, which would lead to wider
                      appeal for the society. In future it might develop as a
                      wide-ranging strategic tool as well by responding to changing
                      demands of the society and stakeholders in view of GHG. 
 
 |